Skip to content
Menu
PersonalAudioNotes
  • Home
  • Who, what and whatnot
    • Who, what
    • …and whatnot
PersonalAudioNotes

TIN P1: silky pleasure

Posted on 3 August 202020 August 2020

P1 promised to be a very uncommon IEM to me, and I must say it did deliver! A very special addition to my personal collection that won’t quit anytime soon.

At-a-glance Card

PROsCONs
Spectacularly calibrated neutral tuning. Very crisp highs might not be in everyone’s taste.
Superfast transients. Some might want more incisive bass.
Relaxing, silky tonality. Lack of emotion on some genres.
Very comfortable (might be subjective)Significant amping required.
Unobvious tip rolling may be required to avoid sibilance (subjective).

Full Device Card

Test setup

Hiby R5 – Balance Ended port – JVC Spiraldot tips – Yinyoo 8*63core 6N Single Crystal Copper cable – Lossless 16/44.1 – 24/96 – 24/192 FLAC tracks.

Signature analysis

TonalityNeutral as for tuning, and superlatively smooth as for presentation. Planar drivers output impact is obvious: transients are lightning fast, everything is clear and polished. Every note is lean as can be – in the good sense, that is polished, unbloated yet bodied, not “thin”. TIN job has been to keep everything as musical as technically possible.
Sub-BassSlightly rolled-off, and not even mainly that. Sub-bass notes are fast and textured, but they hit with kindness so to say.
Even raising presence by means of some EQ shelfing – which is very well received if applied – P1 won’t become the right choice for EDM or other strong-bass-rythmical genres.
Mid BassMore present than sub-bass yet of the same general quality. Notes are mildly bodied, very fast, but most of all they hit in a sort of gentle way. On P1 bass punches fast and precise but doesn’t leave bruises. It’s jabbing, not hooking.
MidsMids are detailed at a very fine grain. Every single breath in voices is rendered with precision and clarity. String instruments are at their best here, this aspect is just phenomenal. On the other hand, transients are so fast that depending on the situation some emotion may be lacking.
Male VocalsQuite elevated and rather warm, they lean-back in terms of overall presence on stage due to the fast transients. Very detailed, simply put very nice.
Female VocalsLess forward than Males, and leaner too. Most of the positive things stated about mids do apply, barrred some occasions where Females come accross a bit too thin. It’s important to mention that I did have to sweat a lot to get rid of sibilance which – luckily – I identified being 100% connected with in-ear resonance, so I could get rid of it with appropriate tip pairing. After rolling many models, the ones doing the right cleansing trick in my own ear canal are JVC Spiraldots (only!). YMMV, and a lot so – many are so lucky as to not possibly experiment any sibilance with P1 no matter the tips
HighsAiry, clair, extended, sparkly and fast. P1 trebles have it all, and then some. Crispy textures offer a high level of detail sensation more as the consequence of clarity than of purely technical (and sometimes dual-bladed) detail retrieval.

Technicalities

SoundstageA sensation of space, mostly in depth terms, is definitely there. My impression is not that of a huge room though, rather a non-crowded one.
ImagingIt’s more layering than imaging what is superb here. Other IEMs make instruments feel more physically distanced one from another on the stage, while P1 “keep the group more closer”.
DetailsAgain, it’s more clarity the word here, rather than detail. Hearing so fast, unsmeared sound gives a very refreshing sensation of cleanness.
Instrument separationAll sounds are prefectly separated, and the separation is not even cut with a knife but rather smoothed with a thin grain file. As mentioned above P1 “keep the group rather close”, but no sound congestion is ever determined by instruments proximity.
DriveabilityTough. Forget a phone, forget any entry level DAP. The absolute minimum requirement to let P1 shine is 200mW@32Ohm.

Physicals

BuildVery solid full metal housing, offering a very convincing durability sensation
FitThe triangular shaped housing, its modest size and the very long nozzles make it very easy to score a good and solid seal almost effortlessly, no matter which kind of eartips are applied – with the sole exception of stock “short + wide bore” silicon ones which are hilariously too short, so much so that the housing nozzle can easily protrude out of their front opening totally screwing the sound.
ComfortExtremely comfortable even for protracted sessions
IsolationAverage at best. The housing is not large enough to fill the concha compeletely which is good for comfort but obviously suboptimal for isolation, which is also not helped by the presence of a front and a back vent.
CablePer se, it’s a nice quality 5N OFC and copper alloy cable, if only not a masterpiece in terms of braiding. Too bad that it’s offered only in 3.5 single ended termination version, which is an obvious myopic choice considering P1’s significant power requirements. I instantly swapped it with a good balanced-ended one, while dedicating it to my T4 pair.

Specifications (declared)

HousingFull metal, very elegant shape and mirror finish
Driver(s)10mm planar magnetic driver
ConnectorMMCX
Cable5N OFC and copper alloy, 3.5mm single ended terminated
Sensitivity96 +/- 3dB
Impedance20 Ω
Frequency Range10Hz to 40kHz
Rated Power10mW
Package / accessories3 pairs of narrow bore silicon tips, 3 pairs of larger bore and shorter silicon tips, 2 pairs of foam tips, velcro cable strap, leatherette coffer, 1 shirt clip
MSRP at this post time$ 169,00

Other opinions & considerations

As many following my Notes know already, I don’t believe in “all rounders” and P1 is definitely not going to change my mind.

It excels – and phenomenally so – in delivering a supremely refined and relaxed acoustic experience. Every segment of the spectrum is rendered in an expertly micro-calibrated way: nothing is lush, nothing is too thin, rythm sections are rendered almost “gently”, although each single beat – bass and highs alike – is there and at the right time and evidence for me to feel it.

Solo or small group classical music – especially strings and pianos -, classic jazz, songwriters, folk & similia are at their top on P1. On a higher level, P1 is the right companion when I am in a self-centered, balanced mood, I am not looking for extra energy to input or expel through music, and I want to have music flow all around and through me effortlessly.

Once I managed to solve all sibilance issues by adopting SpiralDot tips, the sole small personal brush stroke I sometimes want to give P1 is a slight raise in low-bass (low-midbass + sub-bass) presence. Here’re the values I apply:

Preamp  : -4dB
Lowshelf: +2dB  80Hz Q:0,64
Lowshelf: +4dB 150Hz Q:1,1

Wether I want to apply this or not essentially depends on the track or the genre really calling for it, then I do it liberally as such amount adds some welcome warmer body to the overall presentation while keeping P1’s low-bass inherent nature intact: superfast, unbloated, unbleeding.

Comparisons

TIN P1final E1000TIN T4Shuoer Tape
Driver(s)Single planar magneticSingle Dynamic DriverSingle Dynamic DriverSingle DD + Electret tweeter
TonalitySlightly warm neutralBright neutralSlightly-bright neutral, engaging dynamicsWarmish V-shape
BassFlat mid and rolled off sub. Planar superfast transients.Flat mid and rolled off sub. Dry, fast and punchy.Modestly elevated mid and sub. Fast, clean.Very elevated, fast, clean sub. Less elevated, clean, fast, lean mid.
MidsPlanar fast transients, extremely clean and detailed. Male vocals better than females. Somewhat forward, textured, almost purely neutral sounding. Both Male and Female vocals nice and musical. Clear, natural sounding and flat. Recessed but well detailed. Female better than male vocals. EQ correction is well received.
HighsAiry, clair, extended, sparkly, super crisp and fast.
Sibilance if present can be removed with the right tips.
Prominent, quite articulated, not hugely extended.
Some rare sibilance.
Clair, quite extended, well articulated.
May feel excessive at times.
Unfrequent light sibilance removed by tips or deeper insertion.
Elevated, almost bright, high texture, quality and details.
Sibilance tameable by tips selection. Zing on top octave reduced by cable selection, removed by EQing.
SoundstageAbove average size, clarity increases the sensation of spaceVery sizeable, wider than deepAbove averageBig, around the head
ImagingIntimate but never congested. Consistent.Precise and consistentAbove average, consistentVery well distributed, and consistent
DetailsNot too many per se, compensated by crystal clarityAverageAbove averageTop notch both for quantity and quality, both in trebles and sub-bass
SeparationPerfect layering give the impression of good instrument separationAverage, no congestionAverageVery good layering and separation
DriveabilitySerious amping required Average. A good phone is enoughA phone is OKA phone is hardly enough. Amping required if EQing is applied.
Fit & ComfortAlmost perfectExtremely easy fit, subjective comfortFit might be an issue for some. Comfort is OK when fit is easy.Fit is a win or lose. Comfort is OK when fit is easy.
Other notesSuper refined, silky, lovely sound coming at a relatively cheap purchase yet high amping costAlmost-reference flatness and ease of use at a supercheap price Reference neutrality with a hint of brightness, with overall above average technicalitiesSpectacular and hyperdetailed bass and treble rendering
Economics$ 169,00$ 24,00$ 109,00
($ 79,00 deals)
$ 128,00

Interesting links

  • Head-FI P1 review thread
  • Crinacle review

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • TRN Kirin – inoffensive planar
  • Kinera Hodur review
  • Questyle M15
  • Final F7200 – telling voices apart
  • Ikko OH5 Asgard – music better than the rest

Recent Comments

  • alberto on Intime Miyabi – uniquely special
  • John on Intime Miyabi – uniquely special
  • MrWalkman on Experimenting with Sony NW-A55 & MrWalkman’s DMP-A50 vs DMP-A50R firmware
  • alberto on Fiio BTR5 : great sound, terrible vendor value (and I won’t buy Fiio anymore)
  • Phil on Fiio BTR5 : great sound, terrible vendor value (and I won’t buy Fiio anymore)

Archives

  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • April 2022
  • February 2022
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • June 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020

Categories

  • ACCESSORIES
  • AMP
  • DAC
  • DAC-AMP
  • DAP
  • EARBUDS
  • EDUCATION
  • GREAT STUFF
  • HEADPHONES
  • IEM
  • RANTS
  • TWS

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
©2023 PersonalAudioNotes | WordPress Theme by Superbthemes.com